Search:
Be Here Now - was it really so bad?

The next issue of Q, onsale 1st May, celebrates the 10th anniversary of Oasis' controversial third album, Be Here Now. Hailed as a masterpiece upon its 1997 release, its reputation swiftly deteriorated. Today it's usually dismissed as a disastrous, overblown folly - the moment when Oasis, their judgement clouded by drugs and blanket adulation, ran aground on their own sky-high self-belief. Noel Gallagher himself remembers is as "the sound of five men in the studio, on coke, not giving a fuck."

Our cover feature, in which we both reappraise the album and explore the remarkable events surrounding its recording, recounts a tumultuous tale of loathing and excess. This is how producer Owen Morris remembers the sessions: "The only reason anyone was there was the money. Noel had decided Liam was a shit singer. Liam had decided he hated Noel's songs. So on we went. Massive amounts of drugs. Big fights. Bad vibes. Shit recordings."

But was Be Here Now really all that bad? We came across this footage of Noel Gallagher performing Don't Go Away on an obscure Japanese TV show in 1997. Stripped of the dense layers of distorted guitars that cluttered the album version, it emerges as a heartfelt, affecting ballad - easily the equal of, say, Slide Away, or Cast No Shadow. OK, the lyrics are excruciating, but that hardly makes it unique in the Oasis canon.

Whatever you think of the song, the clip is worth watching for Noel's visible embarrassment at performing the song in such bizarre circumstances, surrounded by baffled studio guests and backed by cheesy video footage. Of course, the original version was sung by Noel's brother Liam. Are we alone in thinking Noel actually delivers it with more soul and sensitivity?

Posted by Luke Lewis at 01:44PM | April 25, 2007
Add a Comment

Sorry. Not convinced. Those are some of the laziest lyrics ever composed by man or beast.

Posted by brezhnev at 05:23PM | April 25, 2007

That was some deep lyrics and great song/melody, one of the best off be here now

Posted by 10zin at 06:17PM | April 25, 2007

I still think its one of their best songs. The album is not that bad it still has many classics. Still the biggest moment in music history since the Beatles. For that build up period to Be Here Now, Oasis were biggest band on the planet, still the best!

Posted by Kafes at 08:00PM | April 25, 2007

It's funny how Q are asking whether Be here now was that bad?

ERRRRM Q gave the album 5 stars!
how hypocritical!!!

As for be here now i personally think its a great album. It's only the critics who beg to differ... At the time of the realse this album had loads of praise but when the hype died down it got so much backlash.

Be here now is overlooked by the first two albums which is ashame... as the album does hold some really good tunes.

Posted by Jez at 10:26PM | April 25, 2007

Heard Don't Go Away the other day while shopping in New Zealand. Personally speaking, I think it's a top tune.

Posted by Scott at 11:28PM | April 25, 2007

c'mon it's not bad considering the circumstances recording it. I have Don't Go Away from a David Letterman appearance, it's a classic.

Posted by Alan Geoghegan at 12:32AM | April 26, 2007

in be here now are great songs like Stand By Me or Don't Go Away, and if you to include more, maybe yo could say that all around the world and d'you know what i mean are as great as the other ones, bu i thnik that are a little bit heavyweight cos they are so longer

maybe the album is very longer,

Posted by daniel at 02:52AM | April 26, 2007

its probably theyr weakest work to date but at the time it could have only been a classic! No other band since the beatles where at such a high!! i mean they sold like 700.000 copies in 3 days so be here now is still the fastest selling album in british history!!
but there are still a few classics on it - stand by me - all around the world - don't go away...

Posted by max at 10:21AM | April 26, 2007

"Me and you what's going on?"Bleah,sorry not convinced.
Nice young Noel,unforgivable

Posted by Naa at 01:14PM | April 26, 2007

the songs of be here now ain't that bad, the way they were recorded, is. if the went back re-recording them, stripping them down, it would make a great record! and don't go away is a beautiful song!

Posted by Oliver at 03:05PM | April 26, 2007

There is nothing wrong with Be Here Now or Standing on the shoulders as far as I'm concerned. I only got into Oasis a few years ago, after all the madness, and I can't think of any music by any band that is quite as good. Both Be Here Now, and Standing have the coolest first songs of any album by any band I can think of. Who cares about whether the lyrics are fucking Shakesworth. It's brilliant music, with some of Liam's best vocals ever. Top album from a top band!

Posted by Christopher at 03:06PM | April 26, 2007

c'mon guys! they gave us two great albums and then lost theyre steam fer the two following. be here now has some decent stuff on it. aside from the goofy crap like magic pie. so what if it was a drug infested pile of hoopajoop. it was a lemon among oranges. iwhat made it not quite as good as the two previous was mostly the stigma surrounding it. i mean how do ya follow up whats the story morning glory?

Posted by nicole at 04:51PM | April 26, 2007

The album has a number of great tunes, but the production is simply too bloated and the songs drag on too long--e.g., All Around The World, which would've been killer had it ended at the 4 minute mark.

Posted by luc Richard m'bah a'moute at 08:30PM | April 26, 2007

still listen to fade in/out its a great tune but overall although very listenable its abit poor

Posted by jenny leach at 09:18PM | April 26, 2007

oasis are still the most important band on the planet. but yeah be here now couldve been amazing but i still think it gets a hard time when compared to the first two. bring on the new oasis album!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by mark at 10:38PM | April 26, 2007

The Oasis supposed failures of Oasis stand miles above the successes of every other band. The Arctic Monkeys, Kasabian, The Who, and even The Rolling Stones don't have the entire albums that Oasis have. I challenge you to go song by song on every album and pick the songs you don't want to skip. Oasis only has a few songs in their entire catolouge that you'll skip. Most bands have 3 good songs on their entire CD.
The one album Oasis put out that is just Good is Standing On The Shoulders of Giants and even it has several good songs on it. Here's the track listing for
Be Here Now:
"D'You Know What I Mean?" – 7:42
"My Big Mouth" – 5:02
"Magic Pie" – 7:19
"Stand by Me" – 5:56
"I Hope, I Think, I Know" – 4:22
"The Girl in the Dirty Shirt" – 5:49
"Fade In-Out" – 6:52
"Don't Go Away" – 4:48
"Be Here Now" – 5:13
"All Around the World" – 9:20
"It's Gettin' Better (Man!!)" – 7:00
"All Around the World (Reprise)" – 2:08

half of this album is great. Some of the songs are just ridiculous with all the guitars, but the others are great....
LONG LIVE THE GALLAGHERS & THE NEW LINEUP OF OASIS IS BY FAR THE BEST IT'S EVER BEEN LET'S HOPE ZAK STARKEY STICKS AROUND WITH THE BAND AS WELL......STILL MADFERIT!!!!

Posted by kevin at 02:37AM | April 27, 2007

I'm Australian pretty much a massive fan of Oasis, and believe this album was good and has about 5 songs that I like on it. Now conisider that I brought a Kings of Leon cd recently and there were only 2 or maybe 3 songs on that album I like, (which is pretty much the amount of songs I like on Standing on the Shoulder of Giants. ). Other than that their other 5 Albums (yes I'm counting Masterplan) seem to be 5 of the best most enjoyable albums I have ever listened to Noel is a genious songwriter and Gem and Andy are good and Liam seems to be going alright. So hopefully their next album when ever it is released is goinbg to be worth this long wait

Posted by Matt at 08:40AM | April 27, 2007

Be Here Now is an amazing album!

Posted by Adrian Jayasuriya at 05:18PM | April 27, 2007

It's a great song, and Be Here Now is still better than just about anything else of the last 20 years. The reaction of the Japanese in the video is enough to make it worth watching. I saw Oasis live on their last tour and they're by far the best band in the world today. LIVE FOREVER!

Posted by Land at 05:41PM | April 27, 2007

I loved that album from the first listen and still do now. Don't Go Away is one my favorite oasis songs - its been my ringtone for some time now and whenever people hear it - they ask what is it... then again i live in the US! Also in heavy rotation here from this album is the song "All Around the World". A major cellular service provider uses it for all their national tv and radio spots. I get so happy every time i hear it! Its like 1997 all over again!

Posted by jennifer at 07:13PM | April 27, 2007

Not the best Oasis album, but still ranks up there and actually seems to get better with time!

Posted by jeff mckinney at 09:27PM | April 27, 2007

oasis are my old pervy uncles.

Posted by badger legs at 10:37PM | April 27, 2007

Oasis sadly to say will never be as great as first 2 albums. This is good, love Dont go away. Oasis was biggest in wolrd in 97, i remember as i'm from Chile and the relase of Be Here Now was huge. Not so big now and not much news. Us poor Chileans are now lumped with rubbish like Coldplay and all that rubbish American stuff!

Posted by Santiago at 12:48AM | April 28, 2007

this is what u get when ur on coke. sinces this album they are back to there best and for such a shit ablum i bet u everybody that puts this ablum down can sing every song on it.class sum thing that bands dont have to day.

Posted by pappy at 01:55AM | April 28, 2007

This song is about their mother's illness, don't say its cheesy, megawankerz

Posted by Adam at 06:17AM | April 28, 2007

Ì remember back in the days when this album was about to release, at the beginning I tought it was awesome even better than the first ones, but then few years later I found it bore, of course songs such like this and Stand By Me, D You What I Mean still rocking and still among my favorites, but for me this was the beginning of a very rare time for the band till few years ago when I felt the recover the old rockin spirit that catch me, by the way this show is very very odd, it seems like if he was practicing at somebody`s laundry place.

Posted by Davide at 06:35AM | April 28, 2007

Ì remember back in the days when this album was about to release, at the beginning I tought it was awesome even better than the first ones, but then few years later I found it bore, of course songs such like this and Stand By Me, D You What I Mean still rocking and still among my favorites, but for me this was the beginning of a very rare time for the band till few years ago when I felt the recover the old rockin spirit that catch me, by the way this show is very very odd, it seems like if he was practicing at somebody`s laundry place.

Posted by Davide at 06:36AM | April 28, 2007

...hey, wait! from my corner in mexico i think that Be Here Now is a good (almost GOLD) album ...but is a suposed best band in the worl (in 97)
album, so not reach the great expectations that we put on it...psst!

Posted by muchacho pendenciero at 07:22AM | April 28, 2007

It was and still is poor, lazy attempt to cash in on their previous stuff. None of Oasis' music has stood the test of time really. All very of it's time. Over rated band.

Posted by The Rampant One at 11:27AM | April 28, 2007

What's the Story received such mediocre reviews that the critics were wary of getting it wrong again and hailed it a classic. Thus getting it wrong. Again.

Posted by Jeff at 08:41PM | April 28, 2007

be here now has the best melodies, however the album is overpruduced and the songs are too long. with a good production and the songs shorter, definitely its the best oasis album

Posted by fede at 08:46PM | April 28, 2007

obivously albums like 'Definitely Maybe' and '...Morning Glory' are goin 2 be killer to follow up, especially with all the hype surrounding the scene. although not their best by a long way, i still dont think it deserves its reputation as a poor album. i think to some extent critics turned on it because it was so popular, to create a new buzz and then an eventual revamp of british music in the 90s. 'D'Ya Know What I Mean', 'All Around The World', 'Fade In/Out' are up there with 'Stand By Me' and 'Dont Go Away' as immense songs, and the crazier moments on the album like 'Magic Pie' still provide joy when listening. For people who were coked up throughout the making of the album - and this to be considered the bands worst effot - shows the calibre of Oasis. Many bands would kill for the 'lazy' lyrics of Noel Gallagher, and they still remain a prominent force in British music today.

Posted by laurie at 10:22PM | April 28, 2007

I absolutely loved this album from the first time I heard it. I'll never understand why people slagged off this one, and standing on the the shoulders. There are many great bands, but not one that makes so many great songs on each album. I just love every second of it. Nobody else does that for me. except the guys at www.fortifyband.com. Oasis were and are the best band ever as far as I'm concerned. The fact that theiy're still around is proof of their genuinity. Live forever.

Posted by Chris at 11:13PM | April 28, 2007

It's the second best Oasis album. Magic Pie - ace. Fade In/Out - Wanted Dead or Alive for the 90's. D'ya Know What I Mean - awesome. I hate All Around The World and that's it. Apart from that song it's a screamer. Far superior to Definitely Maybe.

Posted by Llyr at 11:51AM | April 29, 2007

Oasis = overrated. 'Be Here Now' was as good as morning glory, it's just that people realised that morning glory was really bad as well and therefore Oasis were/are an exceptionally overrated boring and bland band, who are still trying to live in the past when they were (unexplicably) popular.

Posted by Paul at 05:59PM | April 29, 2007

since when do drungs and rock and roll not mix? I personally think this is a great album, pity about how long the songs are, and there is quite a bit of helicopter sounds, but all in all i think it's far superior to standing on the shoulder.. and there is no doubt that oasis are one of the best bands of all time, with a rock and roll attitude that is slowly dissapearing for pansies who want to be seen as good dads, and lack that arrogance that i think makes a rock star.

Posted by Mark at 06:24PM | April 29, 2007

You fucking wanker, saying that Oasis = overrated. They were and are the most real act out there, head and shoulders above anybody else, simply because of their attitude. In addition to that comes the music. I still havn't heard one Coldplay album that doesn't bore me to death. I love some of their songs, but i can't listen to a whole album. Same with Kaisers, Monkeys, you name it. Oasis on the other hand are fucking mega from start to finish on everything they've ever done. Even their "poorer" work is head and shoulders above anything else out there, so sod off you jerk-off.

Posted by Lenny at 06:39PM | April 29, 2007

Q should not be allowed to have any opinion on this, the most criminally under rated album of all time. They dont seem to be able to make their mind up at all, do they think it's ** or *****. Great album by the best band of my generation.

Posted by Peter Branigan at 07:26PM | April 29, 2007

Q don't have a clue. Oasis are still the best band around and one day doesn't go by when i'm not listening to or playing one of their songs. As many people have already commented, they're still head and shoulders above any of the bands around today.

Posted by Ben at 10:17PM | April 29, 2007

Lenny... I am really sorry that you seemed to take such exception about my opinion, an opinion that in a free and open society I am entitled to hold, but getting so worked up as you have done I'm not so sure I'm allowed to have it now. Maybe there are a few taboo subjects out there and maybe Oasis are that subject. but I will always think of them as an overhyped, overrated, bland, boring and derivative bunch.

I'm sorry but there is absolutely nothing real about Oasis. They are a band who knows how to play the media perfectly. Have you noticed how they only bitch about fellow musicians when they have something to sell? and I've never been convinced that things like walking off tours and Sibling Rivalry has been nothing more than publicity stunts...

Posted by Paul at 11:43AM | April 30, 2007

I think they should re-record it or remix it and take off all the 28 guitar layers etc and see what it sounds like then

Posted by Stu at 02:55PM | April 30, 2007

Ok Paul, you're entitled to your opinion. I shouldn't have called you a fucking wanker. I'm just really tired of people slagging off Oasis for no reason. I got into them way after all the hype. It was just the music for me, and it's just head and shoulders above anything else i've heard. The first time I heard "Hello" I was just blown away. All used to Coldplay as I was. Don't get me wrong, I like Coldplay, just not for much at a time. And by the way: Bands get interviews when they have new stuff out. THAT'S why oasis only slag others off when they have a new album. I mean, they're just being honest. I also think System of a down is absolute rubbish.
Great album from history's best band.

Posted by Lenny at 09:05AM | May 1, 2007

Wankers critsising Noel... Do it yerself. Be here now rocks & has been great for 10 years.

Posted by Paul at 12:02PM | May 2, 2007

this was at a time when the brothers were flying(literally) but nothing can be as worse as 'little james' on 'standing'. that IS the worst oasis tunes ever(after hey now). the fact that we ARE ALL STILL DEBATING this album to this day shows its jekyl and hyde qualities. rip roaring opening and 'better man' is a tune. i suppose its subjective. all i know is that it pxxxed on blurs offerings late on.

Posted by Peter at 04:54PM | May 3, 2007

I live in Tasmania Australia. Myself and my houemates all bought this the day it came out, cranked it up and partied. It was awesome turned up to ten. The problem is that the production is ridiculous and really only works played very loud. It hides the many great songs on it.

Posted by Matt at 12:57PM | May 4, 2007

I still enjoy listening to Be Here Now 10 years on, mainly due to the fact people don't make albums like that anymore. It was the last big overblown rock and roll album, no one except oasis would/can make an album like this in this day and age of polished production and commercialism. Oasis were back then a real band, and as much as the new line up is better technically and sonically, they have lost that edge they had with (most) of the original members, but hey if they went on like that with all the drink and drunks they would be a mess! Oasis (the Gallaghers) just grew up, and Be Here Now was them in their prime having it, which for me makes it a great record for that on it's own!

Posted by Johnny Curran at 03:34PM | May 7, 2007

Personally I think Oasis is such a highly overrated band, and sorry Q but how many times did you have Oasis on the cover this year alone? There are some other bands out there as well ( don't get me started on Coldplay)

Posted by Evan Slater at 02:40PM | May 20, 2007

I think Oasis is a terrific band through and through and while Definitely Maybe and What's The Story? are great albums, I feel that Be Here Now is easily the best album in their catalog and a masterpiece among rock albums. I get chills when I listen to it all the way through. I don't understand why others don't feel the same way as I do. Probably because people tend to lack objectivity. Just because this was the time when the craziness in the group began does not mean that their artistry suffered. They should be proud of this one.

Posted by Eric Brodsky at 06:12AM | July 28, 2007

Don't Go Away is one of the best songs Oasis have ever done. The album version is absolutely beautiful, and the lyrics are amazing as well.

Posted by Der at 04:46PM | April 14, 2008

This album is awesome. Come to think of it, Oasis have only really done four or five bad songs out of what, 150? It shows how great a band they are when they've managed to retain their place in the top 3 or 4 biggest bands in the world for a good 14 years now. As for Don't Go Away, I think Liam's vocals on this song are perhaps his best ever. I also think its one of the best things Oasis have ever done - this album is my favourite Oasis album

Posted by REd at 06:21PM | June 30, 2008

I love this album man. It doesn'y actually have any bad songs, but the songs don't work well to form a great album if that makes sense.

Posted by Chris at 08:48AM | July 4, 2008

Some of the songs should have been shorter. I wouldn't change a thing about D'You Know What I mean? or My Big Mouth. I think we could have used one more Noel tune, or maybe Stay Young on that album, could have been a single, and IHITIK should have been a B-side. The Fame or Flashbax should have been an A-side. I would shorten Magic Pie, Fade In-Out, It's Gettin' Better, and AATW, and get rid of the stray chorus here or there. I'm a fan of an extra verse over an extra chorus any day.

I still have fond memories of this album and the time in which it was released. Great album! Problem was, they didn't have ONE US-released CD single. I had to buy D'You Know What I Mean?, Stand By Me, AATW, and Don't Go Away as British or Japanese imports (I would have bought them anyway for the B-sides alone, but why no US releases at the height of their fame?). Sony should have done them right and released a couple singles in the US other than just radio/promo-only.

Posted by FJ at 03:44PM | August 25, 2008


Name:
Email address:
Website:
Remember my details:
Comment:
   
1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31
DUETS
Metallica headline our On The Road special; plus Flight Of The Conchords,The Raconteurs and and a very candid Boy George ... all in the new issue

Click here for hundreds more T-shirts
© Bauer Performance . All use is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy